The series in one sentence
The TIER Files is a document-based investigation of Alberta’s industrial carbon-pricing system, following compliance money through the TIER Fund and Emissions Reduction Alberta.
The lead finding
Four fiscal years of audited TIER Fund statements report $590.0 million in innovation and technology grants and $1,088.8 million in transfers to Alberta’s General Revenue Fund.
That works out to about $1.85 transferred for every dollar granted from fiscal 2022 through fiscal 2025.
The fund also reported an accumulated surplus of $1,105.4 million at 31 March 2025. Accumulated surplus is a balance-sheet stock. The grants and transfers above are four-year flows.
The law permits qualifying TIER Fund money to be transferred to general revenue. The reporting question concerns what those transferred dollars funded after they entered the government’s general accounts. The public statements record the transfer out. A dollar-for-dollar account of subsequent spending would require a separate reconciliation.
Read Part 1: The Billion-Dollar Detour
Verified findings
ERA held $539.5 million in cash and investments
At 31 May 2025, ERA reported $309.5 million in cash, $40.0 million in short-term investments, and $190.0 million in long-term investments. It reported $71.7 million in project expense for fiscal 2025.
The $539.5 million balance was about 7.5 times that year’s project expense. This compares a point-in-time balance with one year’s expense and should be read as scale rather than as a liquidity forecast.
Read Part 3: The Climate Fund That Became a Bank
A $50 million allocation produced about $20.3 million in cash
ERA’s fiscal 2025 statements describe an August 2024 provincial allocation of $50.0 million, reduced by $29.7 million, equal to ERA’s fiscal 2024 interest income. An October 2024 amendment added a continuing mechanism for reducing provincial payments by interest earned on government funding.
Source: ERA audited financial statements for the year ended 31 May 2025, Note 3.
Cancelled and terminated agreements exceeded project expense in fiscal 2025
ERA reported $82,737,012 in contribution agreements cancelled or terminated during fiscal 2025. It reported $71.7 million in project expense for the same year.
These figures measure different things. Cancellation removes the unearned balance of an agreement; project expense records amounts earned by projects during the year. The $82.7 million is agreement value removed, rather than cash paid and recovered.
About 55 to 60 cents per committed dollar reached project expense
The series reconstructs about $650 million in cumulative project expense from ERA and predecessor CCEMC statements covering fiscal 2010 through fiscal 2025. ERA’s June 2026 public material said it had committed $1.17 billion toward 352 projects since 2009.
The resulting comparison is about 55 to 60 cents in project expense for each committed dollar. This is the series’ reconstruction. The fiscal 2015 annual report was published without financial statements, so the lifetime project-expense total includes an estimate for that year.
ERA disclosed payments to companies owned by senior management
ERA’s fiscal 2025 statements say program management expenses include remuneration to “companies owned by senior management who report directly to the board.” The reported amount was $321,613 in fiscal 2025, with a $304,999 comparative for fiscal 2024.
The statements disclose the category and amount. Company names, owner identities, service descriptions, and procurement details would require additional records.
Read Part 7: The Companies the Board Pays Itself
About Lars J. Frank
Lars J. Frank is the pen-name author of The TIER Files at The Sense of Nonsense. His reporting follows Alberta’s industrial carbon money through audited statements, public accounts, regulatory filings, and funding records. The series covers the TIER Fund, Emissions Reduction Alberta, project disbursements, carbon accounting, and the gap between public announcements and the underlying ledger.
For a short introduction:
Lars J. Frank writes The TIER Files, a document-based investigation of Alberta’s industrial carbon-pricing system and the public money moving through it.
Identity verification can be discussed privately where an editor requires it.
Available for comment
Frank can speak to:
- the TIER Fund’s audited revenue, grants, transfers, and accumulated surplus;
- the difference between a funding commitment and a project disbursement;
- ERA’s cash, investment, interest, and cancellation disclosures;
- checking government funding claims against audited statements;
- environmental-attribute accounting across provincial systems;
- related-party disclosures and the limits of what they establish;
- public reporting reforms supported by the documentary record.
Reporting method
The work starts with the audited statement or governing record. Line items are transcribed in their original units, comparative figures are checked across consecutive years, and ratios are recalculated from the published values.
Stocks, annual flows, commitments, expenses, and forecasts are kept separate. Estimates are labelled. Each article states the strongest reasonable alternative explanation and links the source record with a page or note reference.
Corrections, documents, and tips are welcome at [email protected].
Charts available for publication
Charts may be reproduced with credit to The Sense of Nonsense / Lars J. Frank. Please preserve the period labels and source line.
TIER Fund transfers and grants
Caption: Four-year innovation and technology grants of $590.0 million compared with $1,088.8 million transferred to Alberta’s General Revenue Fund. Fiscal 2022 through fiscal 2025. Source: TIER Fund audited statements.
TIER Fund accumulated surplus
Caption: TIER Fund accumulated surplus increased from $336.8 million at 31 March 2022 to $1,105.4 million at 31 March 2025. Source: TIER Fund audited statements.
ERA cash and investments
Caption: ERA reported $539.5 million in cash and investments at 31 May 2025 and $71.7 million in fiscal 2025 project expense. The comparison is a balance divided by one year’s expense. Source: ERA audited statements.
Agreements cancelled or terminated
Caption: ERA reported $82.7 million in agreements cancelled or terminated in fiscal 2025, compared with $71.7 million in project expense. Source: ERA audited statements.
Questions reporters tend to ask
Is the transfer to general revenue legal?
Yes. Alberta law permits qualifying TIER Fund money to be transferred to the General Revenue Fund. The finding is the amount transferred. Tracing those dollars into later spending would require a separate published reconciliation.
What does “committed” mean?
ERA contribution agreements generally pay against milestones. The audited statements distinguish project expense from outstanding commitments, so a commitment can remain unpaid for years.
What did Part 5 establish about double counting?
It documented overlapping funding, registry, and biomethane-purchase systems. A specific double count remains unproven and would require evidence tying Alberta offset serials to the gigajoules sold under the BCUC records.
When is the next statutory TIER review due?
Order in Council 369/2025 moved the TIER Regulation review deadline from 31 December 2026 to 31 December 2030. Government fact sheets carrying the earlier date predate that amendment.
Primary records
- Government of Alberta, Environment and Protected Areas Annual Report 2024-2025, TIER Fund audited financial statements, pp. 52-74: annual-report collection
- Government of Alberta, Environment and Protected Areas Annual Reports 2023-2024 and 2022-2023, TIER Fund comparative statements: annual-report collection
- Emissions Reduction Alberta, audited financial statements for the year ended 31 May 2025: financial statements PDF
- Emissions Reduction Alberta, fiscal 2010 through fiscal 2024 statements: annual reports
- Auditor General of Alberta, Report of the Auditor General, December 2023, p. 79: report PDF
- Order in Council 369/2025, s. 23: King’s Printer
Contact
Lars J. Frank
[email protected]
Please include your outlet, deadline, and the finding or document you want to discuss.